Untenable and its opposite tenable come to us from Old French tenir ("to hold, have possession of") and ultimately from Latin tenēre ("to hold, occupy, possess"). We tend to use untenable in situations where an idea or position is so off base that holding onto it is unjustified or inexcusable. One way to hold onto the meaning of untenable is to associate it with other tenēre descendants whose meanings are associated with "holding" or "holding onto." Tenacious ("holding fast") is one example. Others are contain, detain, sustain, maintain, and retain.
Example Sentences
The Agriculture Department is in an untenable position. With the two hats that it wears—one to protect consumer health and the other to help farmers sell food—it cannot tell us to eat fewer calories. After all, fewer calories generally mean less food, which would fly in the face of the department's mandate to help farmers. Marian Burros, New York Times, 14 Aug. 2002But scholars are citizens, too, and if it is wrongheaded to demand political payoff from basic research, it would be equally untenable to demand that research be quarantined from the real-world considerations that weigh so heavily upon us. Henry Louis Gates, Jr., New York Times, 4 Apr. 1998All the theories of the Moon's origin proposed before the Apollo Moon landings of 1969 … became untenable when the rocks returned from the Moon proved to be as old as the Earth and significantly dissimilar.Physics Today, January 1997The problem was then resolved—not by finding that the conduct in question was justified, because that would have offended the judge's sense of order, and not by rejecting the applicability of the defense, which would have led to a reportable opinion and an appeal—but through a dismissal of the charges on the wholly untenable ground that the prosecution had not proved its case beyond a reasonable doubt. Edward N. Costikyan, New York Times Book Review, 13 Mar. 1988
Recent Examples on the WebBut waiting until spring 2023 seemed untenable as well. Chris Bieri, Anchorage Daily News, 17 Sep. 2022 By seizing the two cities, Ukrainian forces threatened to encircle completely thousands of Russian troops in Izyum, making its defense untenable and forcing Russia to withdraw them. Tom Soufi Burridge, ABC News, 10 Sep. 2022 For 20 years, Western powers deployed soldiers, sank billions of dollars and made untenable promises to citizens of this terrorized South Asian country. Lovia Gyarkye, The Hollywood Reporter, 9 Sep. 2022 If keeping Jackson in 2023 somehow proved untenable, the Ravens’ potential succession plans would be limited. Jonas Shaffer, Baltimore Sun, 9 Sep. 2022 After around two months, Romanova says, continually moving to new domains became expensive and untenable. Matt Burgess, WIRED, 8 Sep. 2022 That is small solace to shareholders getting smaller coupons, but the previous payout looked untenable. Spencer Jakab, WSJ, 8 Sep. 2022 State aid missed 2,363 providers, a reflection of disinterest in government help, even as the child care business model becomes increasingly untenable. Luca Powell And Derek Kravitz, Detroit Free Press, 28 Aug. 2022 However, some analysts fear China’s rapid military buildup is making this strategy increasingly untenable. Alicia Chen, Washington Post, 25 Aug. 2022 See More